Seed oils are having their moment right now, and not in a good way. Scroll through social media and you’ll see claims that they’re “toxic,” “poison,” “the root of inflammation,” or “destroying your metabolism.” But like most controversial nutrition topics, the truth is far more nuanced.
As holistic and functional nutritionists, our role is to help people make informed decisions – not fear-based ones. So today, we’re breaking down the science, the hype, and the real-world considerations around seed oils so you can confidently guide clients using a grounded, evidence-based, and whole-body perspective.
What Are Seed Oils?
Seed oils are plant-based oils derived through the extraction and processing of different seeds.
Some of the most common ones include:
- Canola oil.
- Sunflower oil.
- Soybean oil.
- Corn oil.
- Cottonseed oil.
- Grapeseed oil.
- Safflower oil.
They’re used everywhere: in packaged foods, restaurant meals, and especially for frying. They’re popular because they’re affordable, shelf-stable, and have a neutral taste, making them easy to add to almost anything.
Why Seed Oils Became Controversial
There are four main reasons seed oils recently began to spark concern:
1. High Omega-6 Content
Seed oils are rich in linoleic acid, an omega-6 fatty acid. Omega-6 is essential – but excessive intake relative to omega-3s can promote inflammation.
2. Industrial Processing
Many seed oils are extracted using high heat, pressure, and chemical solvents like hexane. High heat may degrade the fats and form oxidation byproducts.
3. Prevalence in Ultra-Processed Foods
Seed oils show up in packaged snacks, chips, fast foods, baked goods, margarine, and frozen meals. Is the oil the problem, the processed food itself, or both?
4. Social Media Simplification
“Seed oils are toxic” is catchier than “Seed oils are complex and context-dependent.”
What the Research Actually Says
A functional nutrition approach looks at the whole picture – biochemistry, physiology, the nutrient context, lifestyle, and individual variation.
Here’s what we know from the evidence:
1. Omega-6 Alone Does Not Automatically Cause Inflammation
Most research shows that omega-6 intake, including linoleic acid, does not increase inflammatory markers on its own. In fact, several studies show the opposite: higher linoleic acid intake is linked to lower inflammation and improved heart health.
What matters most is the ratio of omega-6 to omega-3, not omega-6 itself.
Modern diets average a ratio of 26:1 or higher. Traditionally, humans ate closer to 2:1 or 3:1.
Key takeaway: The problem is usually more about omega-3 deficiency, not omega-6 abundance.
2. The Processing of Seed Oils Matters More Than the Oil Itself
Refined oils may contain oxidized fatty acids, trans fat byproducts, lipid peroxides, and chemical residues in small amounts.
Oxidation increases when oils are exposed to high heat, especially during deep frying or repeated heating (think: fast food fryers).
Key takeaway: Cold-pressed, minimally processed oils behave very differently than heavily refined industrial oils.
3. Seed Oils Are Mostly a Marker for Ultra-Processed Foods
Nearly all “seed oils are bad” studies look at populations consuming fast food, processed meats, pastries and desserts, fried foods, and packaged snacks – And we can’t isolate the oil from the entire food environment.
Key takeaway: The packaged food is causing inflammation and metabolic stress more than the seed oil itself.
4. Seed Oils Can Be Stable and Heart-Healthy in Certain Forms
Cold-pressed sunflower, safflower, or grapeseed oils used at low heat show an improved LDL profile, stable inflammatory markers, and high vitamin E content (natural antioxidant).
Key takeaway: Not all seed oils are equal, and not all uses are harmful.
So… Are Seed Oils Really Toxic? A Whole-Person Answer
From a holistic + functional nutrition standpoint, the answer is:
Not inherently – but the context, quality, and individual matter.
Here’s the breakdown:
When Seed Oils May Cause Problems
1. When Used in High-Heat Cooking: Polyunsaturated oils are more prone to oxidation when heated beyond their smoke point. This vulnerability can also happen during high-heat industrial processing, which is why cold-pressed oils with low-heat or cold use are best.
2. When Clients Eat a Lot of Ultra-Processed Foods: Chips, crackers, pastries, fried foods, and fast food = inflammatory, seed oil or not.
3. When Omega-3 Intake Is Low: A high omega-6 load without balancing omega-3s may tilt the body toward inflammation.
4. When There’s Existing Metabolic, Mitochondrial, or Inflammatory Dysfunction: Clients with insulin resistance, autoimmune issues, gut disorders, or chronic stress may be more reactive. Sometimes it depends on the context of the oil, and sometimes it depends on the context of the individual.
When Seed Oils Are Not a Concern
1. In Whole-Food Eating Patterns: A generally nutrient-dense diet makes occasional seed oils largely irrelevant.
2. When Consumed Cold or Unheated: Seed oils in dressings, hummus, and cold dishes are far more stable.
3. When Using High-Quality, Cold-Pressed Oils: Minimal processing = fewer oxidation products.
4. When Omega-3s Are Adequate: Fish, algae, flax, chia, and walnuts restore balance.
A Functional Nutrition Approach to Fats
Instead of demonizing seed oils, we aim to rebalance dietary fats.
Prioritize:
- extra virgin olive oil (cold + medium heat).
- avocado oil (high heat).
- grass-fed butter or ghee.
- coconut oil.
- omega-3 sources: salmon, sardines, chia, flax, hemp.
Use Mindfully:
- cold-pressed sunflower, safflower, grapeseed, sesame.
- occasionally for medium-heat cooking.
Minimize:
- deep-fried foods.
- repeatedly heated oils.
- industrial ultra-processed foods.
What to Tell Clients (In Simple Language)
Here’s an easy script:
“Seed oils aren’t poisonous, but they’re common in processed foods that are inflammatory. Focus on whole foods first, use stable oils for cooking, boost your omega-3s, and you don’t need to fear the occasional seed oil.”
Clients respond to simplicity far better than fear-based messaging.
Final Thoughts
Seed oils on their own are typically not the root cause of chronic inflammation. However, ultra-processed foods, frequent high-heat frying, low omega-3 intake, chronic stress, and nutrient-poor diets all play a far more significant role.
A holistic, functional approach is rooted in nuance. In holistic nutrition, we take a bio-individual approach – looking at the whole body, the full dietary pattern, and the overall lifestyle of each person who walks through our doors. More often than not, it’s more the patterns and deeper context that drive chronic issues far more than a single ingredient.
Ready to Start Studying with Us?
Every practitioner begins with a single step, and yours begins here. Download the NutraPhoria brochure to learn more about our programs and how we can help you build a career in holistic nutrition that changes lives.
